Here’s a common situation: A health center provides a service for years (psychiatry, as an example). One day, that psychiatrist leaves, and the health center begins a search to fill that vacancy. But because of certain circumstances (rural location, national shortage of providers, non-English language requirements, etc.), the health center struggles to find a good replacement. This is usually when the health center reaches out to our team and asks, “How long do we keep trying before we throw in the towel and remove this service from our Form 5A?”
This is an important question because health centers are required by HRSA to maintain a Form 5A that accurately records the services provided by the health center. But more than documenting correctly, the health center must actually provide certain required services, as written in federal statute. These are listed in HRSA’s Service Descriptors document.
We are not aware of any guidance that sets a deadline for submitting a change in scope after a vacancy interrupts a service. We’ve asked BPHC this question directly, and they didn’t give us a timeline either. So instead of a deadline, we walk health centers through a few questions and share our own rule of thumb.
Is the service “required” or “additional”?
Required services must stay on Form 5A, so the real decision is how soon to change the way you provide them. Additional services give you more leeway, including the option of removing them entirely from Form 5A. Depending on the change, you’ll submit either a scope adjustment or a formal change in scope request. You can read more about these options in our previous blog post about this topic.
Is this a service that can be provided another way?
If you can’t find a full-time W-2 employee, can you find someone who is willing to be an individual contractor (1099), or do you have an agency that might be able to provide temporary services? Could you share services with a neighboring health center for a limited time? What other options might you have that could provide the service differently?
Could you argue that you are “actively working to fill the vacancy”?
When we talk about “actively working,” we mean concerted efforts to recruit staff. This may include:
Posting on multiple job boards
Interviewing candidates
Advertising on local radio stations
Partnering with academic institutions
Hiring a professional recruiter
Recruiting at professional association events
If all your health center has done is put up a “We’re Hiring” post, it might be difficult to argue to a HRSA reviewer that your team has been “actively working” to fill the vacancy.
What does an “unsuccessful” search look like in your situation?
Is it that you are not receiving any applicants at all? Are you interviewing and offering positions, but unable to pay a wage that convinces the candidate to accept the position? Do candidates accept the position but then leave quickly after working there for only a short time? Do you feel like your team has gotten creative and tried every idea you can think of to attract candidates? Or is your idea of an “unsuccessful search” simply that you don’t have 500 candidates beating down your door to come work for you?
Have you discussed this with your board?
Under Chapter 19 of the Health Center Program Compliance Manual, the health center’s governing board is responsible for approving the health center’s sites, services, and hours of operation. As services change, it is critical to keep your board in the loop and consult them for guidance. Often, board members are recruited specifically because of their social and community networks, and tapping into these resources may be helpful in filling vacancies. Also, board members frequently have leadership or human resource management experience and can offer suggestions.
Have you discussed this with your federal Project Officer?
Many Project Officers (POs) hold regular meetings with their health centers. It’s always a good idea to run situations like these by your federal representative. They hear about these types of challenges all the time. Not only does this keep your PO from being surprised (HRSA doesn’t like surprises or finding out things about their health centers on the 6 o’clock news), but it also provides the opportunity to benefit from their knowledge and expertise. They might be able to problem-solve with you a bit and suggest strategies to try that you may not have thought of. If you’d rather ask BPHC a general question, submit it through the BPHC Contact Form (under the “Change in Scope” section).
Our rule of thumb
These aren’t HRSA deadlines, but they’re what we recommend:
If a required service is interrupted and you haven’t restored it within two weeks, talk with your PO. Because the service is required, your PO should hear about it early.
For an additional service, bring it up (with your PO) once you’ve been actively recruiting for 30 days without success.
In the end, the decision is yours to make and defend. If you can show a real recruitment effort, you’ve looked at other ways to deliver the service, and your board and PO know where things stand, you’ll be in a strong position whatever you decide. The goal is a Form 5A that matches what patients can actually access today.
If you’d like to work through these questions together, schedule time with one of our HRSA compliance experts today!
AI Disclaimer
This blog post was created 100% without the assistance of generative Artificial Intelligence (AI). It was written by a real, living (albeit fallible and quirky) human (specifically, Kyle Vath).

